This place is absolutely phenomenal! The food is so good and definitely authentic (no peas in the carbonara here). Since coming back from Italy, this is the only place that measures up
Also, We went for a birthday and we got a card which I thought was really sweet. If I lived closer, I'd be there all the time. Definitely worth the drive.
James “JimandCathleen” Vieceli
-
June 22, 2025
Flies. Let’s start there. Too many for a good restaurant. Yes, it’s hot out and their ac could not keep up.
Bread was outstanding.
Burrata was great.
Special. Wage raviloi. Steak way over cooked.
Linguine Frutti Di Mare. Good
Cheese Wheel Fettuccine with Shrimp. Good
Fettuccine Filetto. Good
Gelato- Good
Italian margarita. Good. Very sweet.
So to wrap up.
Things were fine to good, not great.
Liliana Fuenmayor
-
April 27, 2025
This restaurant has a cozy vibe, good service and the food is delicious, we ordered a gorgonzola risotto that was delicious and a Valtellini that I could say was the best! I highly recommend this place
Kenzie Hart
-
January 06, 2025
We ordered the a variety of drinks, caprese, the parmesan wheel for two, and cannoli cake. Everything was absolutely fantastic. Delicious food and great service. Good value for the quality of food and loved the live piano player. Highly recommend!
P C Bucklin
-
June 28, 2025
Great restaurant in Pendleton. My selection was a wagu steak done two ways. Love them both. Also a mushroom ravioli.
Our Address
103 E State St, Pendleton, IN 46064, USA
Claim Listing: Catello’s Italian Art Cuisine
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
This place is absolutely phenomenal! The food is so good and definitely authentic (no peas in the carbonara here). Since coming back from Italy, this is the only place that measures up Also, We went for a birthday and we got a card which I thought was really sweet. If I lived closer, I'd be there all the time. Definitely worth the drive.
Flies. Let’s start there. Too many for a good restaurant. Yes, it’s hot out and their ac could not keep up. Bread was outstanding. Burrata was great. Special. Wage raviloi. Steak way over cooked. Linguine Frutti Di Mare. Good Cheese Wheel Fettuccine with Shrimp. Good Fettuccine Filetto. Good Gelato- Good Italian margarita. Good. Very sweet. So to wrap up. Things were fine to good, not great.
This restaurant has a cozy vibe, good service and the food is delicious, we ordered a gorgonzola risotto that was delicious and a Valtellini that I could say was the best! I highly recommend this place
We ordered the a variety of drinks, caprese, the parmesan wheel for two, and cannoli cake. Everything was absolutely fantastic. Delicious food and great service. Good value for the quality of food and loved the live piano player. Highly recommend!
Great restaurant in Pendleton. My selection was a wagu steak done two ways. Love them both. Also a mushroom ravioli.