We took grandma with us and all of us enjoyed everything very much. I see they have been getting stellar reviews for a long time, so mine can’t really add anything new except to confirm the good reviews. Good service, tasty good food, pleasant peaceful atmosphere in a nice homey town.
Gina Hughes (G Hughes)
-
April 26, 2024
We took my Italian mamma here for her birthday. Great staff! Great food. I hate to say I devoured most of my ravioli before I remembered to take a picture. Mom had Lamb, which was excellent. They made something that wasn’t on the menu for my sister at her request. Everything we had was so good.
Vanessa Kenworthy
-
March 31, 2024
We drove an hour to try Catello's after we heard about it in an online foodie group. Everything we heard was true. This place is fantastic! We were greeted by a super friendly hostess who showed us right to our table. Our waitress followed right after and was super helpful since it was our first time. We ordered a bottle of wine, which was great and house salads to start, also good. We decided to order the cheese wheel since that drew us there and we added the black truffle. The chef came out with the cheese wheel and gave us the background of it while he heated it and then tossed our noodles. He added the pork bits, truffle oil and then super thinly sliced truffle. I can't explain the light creaminess of this sauce and the truffle just sets it off. We ended the evening by trying the creme brulee and we weren't disappointed. It was wonderful! The atmosphere was romantic, there was a piano player, and the low lighting really set the mood. Great date night celebration for us. Highly recommended!
Ipek M
-
May 03, 2024
We had a lovely dinner at Catello’s, a genuine Italian restaurant in Pendleton run by Chef Catello from Napoli. It’s like a fresh Mediterranean breeze in Indiana. It has wide selection of seafood, meat and pasta options. I’m particularly impressed with the visual representation, freshness and burst of flavors of Ravioli Catello’s. Salmon caviar and passion fruit pearl made this Primi Piatti my favorite dish here already. My husband’s choice was Agnelli & Caprino. It wasn’t as impressive as Ravioli but the lamb was cooked properly and it was extremely filling. What’s more important is they say they cook all their food with EVOO, not some vegetable or seed oils. We will certainly come back to try other options in the menu. Bravo Catello’s!
Tiffany L
-
January 20, 2024
Phenomenal Italian restuarant. The atmosphere was so peaceful including nice decor, calm music, and beautiful chandeliers. The service was excellent. Everyone worked together as a team and were very attentive.
We got the gnocchi, mushroom ravioli, bruchetta, and Tiramisu. All were so delicious. You could taste the freshness and that high end ingredients were used. I love that its downtown pendleton. Being on the corner, the view is great as well.
Our Address
103 E State St, Pendleton, IN 46064, USA
Claim Listing: Catello’s Italian Art Cuisine
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
We took grandma with us and all of us enjoyed everything very much. I see they have been getting stellar reviews for a long time, so mine can’t really add anything new except to confirm the good reviews. Good service, tasty good food, pleasant peaceful atmosphere in a nice homey town.
We took my Italian mamma here for her birthday. Great staff! Great food. I hate to say I devoured most of my ravioli before I remembered to take a picture. Mom had Lamb, which was excellent. They made something that wasn’t on the menu for my sister at her request. Everything we had was so good.
We drove an hour to try Catello's after we heard about it in an online foodie group. Everything we heard was true. This place is fantastic! We were greeted by a super friendly hostess who showed us right to our table. Our waitress followed right after and was super helpful since it was our first time. We ordered a bottle of wine, which was great and house salads to start, also good. We decided to order the cheese wheel since that drew us there and we added the black truffle. The chef came out with the cheese wheel and gave us the background of it while he heated it and then tossed our noodles. He added the pork bits, truffle oil and then super thinly sliced truffle. I can't explain the light creaminess of this sauce and the truffle just sets it off. We ended the evening by trying the creme brulee and we weren't disappointed. It was wonderful! The atmosphere was romantic, there was a piano player, and the low lighting really set the mood. Great date night celebration for us. Highly recommended!
We had a lovely dinner at Catello’s, a genuine Italian restaurant in Pendleton run by Chef Catello from Napoli. It’s like a fresh Mediterranean breeze in Indiana. It has wide selection of seafood, meat and pasta options. I’m particularly impressed with the visual representation, freshness and burst of flavors of Ravioli Catello’s. Salmon caviar and passion fruit pearl made this Primi Piatti my favorite dish here already. My husband’s choice was Agnelli & Caprino. It wasn’t as impressive as Ravioli but the lamb was cooked properly and it was extremely filling. What’s more important is they say they cook all their food with EVOO, not some vegetable or seed oils. We will certainly come back to try other options in the menu. Bravo Catello’s!
Phenomenal Italian restuarant. The atmosphere was so peaceful including nice decor, calm music, and beautiful chandeliers. The service was excellent. Everyone worked together as a team and were very attentive. We got the gnocchi, mushroom ravioli, bruchetta, and Tiramisu. All were so delicious. You could taste the freshness and that high end ingredients were used. I love that its downtown pendleton. Being on the corner, the view is great as well.