Casa Santa Restaurant

13521 Tegler Dr, Noblesville, IN 46060, USA

About Casa Santa Restaurant

4.4 / 5

from reviews

    Jack Lawrence
    -
    March 19, 2025

    The atmosphere was amazing. Some of the area near the windows were closed off, but the seating and decor is excellent. Sopas and chorizo dip to start were so good. My date had the fajitas (pictured) and I had the carnival plate. Both were delicious. The cocktails were strong and flavorful. A little pricier than some restaurants but well worth it. 35 minute drive from me, but I will be back often. Go, have a cocktail try one of the specialty dishes. You can thank me later.

    Nathan McGarity
    -
    December 28, 2024

    The interior of this place is very nice. It gives off a modern 70s vibe. The staff is extremely friendly and the place is very clean. The seating is comfortable and there is a wide choice of where you can be sat. The chips and salsa are very good. The food is good but nothing spectacular. The food presentation is impressive. I ordered a beef taco, a tamale, and a beef enchilada. My wife ordered the tamale and an enchilada . I give this place an A for comfort and atmosphere and a B for the food. We payed $17 for the pick 2 combo and $19 for the pick 3 combo. It was a Saturday at about 1:30PM. We were sat immediately. They have menu items up to $35 a plate. This is a good place on a Saturday afternoon or a date night perhaps.

    jodi ferguson
    -
    November 17, 2024

    This place is very nice! It’s a good special occasions. (Date Night, Birthday) restaurant. We got the freshly made guacamole appetizer it’s made at the table. It was good but a tad bit salty for myself. Then we got the Dinner of pick 3 so we could try a little taste of everything. The taco, enchiladas and quesadillas were all pretty good. It’s just like other Mexican restaurants food. My margarita was tasty. Our Bill was about 60$ for what we got. We were on the cheaper side because we split our meal. Overall I would go back on a special occasion.

    kruthi p
    -
    March 13, 2025

    Great ambiance and some good food. Some menu items that I haven’t seen in other Mexican places. Some items based on/similar to sister restaurant, Verde. Alambre was a great concept, except none of it was hot when it came to our table. Corn Tortillas were great. My son loved his Arroz Con Pollo. The tableside gauc was exceptional. Service was a little spotty but seemed they were overwhelmed with number of guests. All in all a great spot.

    Paul Main
    -
    February 02, 2025

    OK, it was my first time here and I will be back. If you are looking for a great Mexican place that is higher class, this is the place. I have always loved mayan food and their Devour menu has one option currently and it is amazing, the Cochinita Pibil is a pork Mayan dish that will not dissapoint. You can eat here and not break the bank or you can go wild and end up needing a loan. The classic side of the menu has the traditional meals you would expect. The middle of the menu is for those that want to spend more. Everything I had here was out of this world awesome, so I don't mind spending more. The Empanadas were the best I have ever had. I would go for just these alone. This is the high end Mexican food you have been wanting. It was a very nice change and has my highest rating. I left very full and very satisfied. Enjoy this amazing experience.

    Casa Santa Restaurant

    Our Address

    13521 Tegler Dr, Noblesville, IN 46060, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    Would you like to add your business to our site? It’s FREE! Please click the button now.