All in all it wasn't bad. I wish it was cooked to medium like I ordered. It was delivered more well done to me. The cottage cheese I wouldn't order again. I'm kinda a Cottage Cheese snob. 🤪 I will try something else next time. I'm thinking the wings.🤔
Caiden Doan
-
June 06, 2026
I usually never leave negative reviews because it’s just not who I am, but I felt this experience needed to be mentioned.
I walked into the bar, sat at the bar top, and ordered a beer. After that, it took about 25–30 minutes to get the bartender’s attention so I could place a food order. During that time, I felt overlooked as a customer despite trying to get attention and even waving my menu.
The food itself was very good, and I enjoyed what I ordered. My only concern was the lack of attentiveness from the staff. I hope the team can work on acknowledging customers more quickly, especially those seated at the bar who are clearly trying to place an order.
Hollie Snier
-
March 22, 2026
They were BUSY last evening but the staff was outstanding! We got there right as dinner was kicking off, the young man in the front let us know it was just a minute to be sat as they had a lot of parties. He was working his tail off clearing tables. When we finally got to seats our server was very sweet and said she would get to us in just a second she had to check on a party’s food outside. We didn’t wait long but the other two ladies serving smiled and checked on us. Everyone there was so happy with one another, we saw multiple times they checked on each other and laughed together it was wonderful! My husband said he would have just thrown in the towel and went home he thought it was too much! Didn’t understand how they all kept such sweet faces the whole time! We come here unlike other places in the area because we are treated like family but it’s clear to see the staff here love being here! That is asking a lot now a days! Spend your money on the small places that still work hard and take pride in doing their best. The food was delicious, we shared the prince deans wings and spinach dip. Perfect every time!
Chris R
-
September 01, 2024
Love this place. Being from the UK this place is pretty close to creating an atmosphere that feels like home. The staff are super lovely and friendly and remember my name and have my drink sat at the bar by the time I’ve walked in and sat down. The soccer is always on and the atmosphere is great when they open early for the games. Very nice support structure to each other and you can tell by the way the staff look out for each other. They all have their super cool bar / soccer related t shirts on and they enjoy a shot or two with the clientele. Food is awesome if a little pricey nowadays. Highly recommend the wings. Best wings in town in my personal opinion. That signature sauce!!! Yum!!!
wil adams
-
June 24, 2026
We chose Chatham tap to watch the World Cup on a Sunday night, and was pleasantly surprised. We had a nice young man as a waiter, who was very attentive and helpful. Our food was fantastic for a sports bar. All TVs were on the soccer game, and overall, it saved our night because we had to walk out of the pub up the street on the corner, due to horrific service. Will be back!
Our Address
8211 E 116th St #120, Fishers, IN 46038, USA
Claim Listing: Chatham Tap Fishers
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
All in all it wasn't bad. I wish it was cooked to medium like I ordered. It was delivered more well done to me. The cottage cheese I wouldn't order again. I'm kinda a Cottage Cheese snob. 🤪 I will try something else next time. I'm thinking the wings.🤔
I usually never leave negative reviews because it’s just not who I am, but I felt this experience needed to be mentioned. I walked into the bar, sat at the bar top, and ordered a beer. After that, it took about 25–30 minutes to get the bartender’s attention so I could place a food order. During that time, I felt overlooked as a customer despite trying to get attention and even waving my menu. The food itself was very good, and I enjoyed what I ordered. My only concern was the lack of attentiveness from the staff. I hope the team can work on acknowledging customers more quickly, especially those seated at the bar who are clearly trying to place an order.
They were BUSY last evening but the staff was outstanding! We got there right as dinner was kicking off, the young man in the front let us know it was just a minute to be sat as they had a lot of parties. He was working his tail off clearing tables. When we finally got to seats our server was very sweet and said she would get to us in just a second she had to check on a party’s food outside. We didn’t wait long but the other two ladies serving smiled and checked on us. Everyone there was so happy with one another, we saw multiple times they checked on each other and laughed together it was wonderful! My husband said he would have just thrown in the towel and went home he thought it was too much! Didn’t understand how they all kept such sweet faces the whole time! We come here unlike other places in the area because we are treated like family but it’s clear to see the staff here love being here! That is asking a lot now a days! Spend your money on the small places that still work hard and take pride in doing their best. The food was delicious, we shared the prince deans wings and spinach dip. Perfect every time!
Love this place. Being from the UK this place is pretty close to creating an atmosphere that feels like home. The staff are super lovely and friendly and remember my name and have my drink sat at the bar by the time I’ve walked in and sat down. The soccer is always on and the atmosphere is great when they open early for the games. Very nice support structure to each other and you can tell by the way the staff look out for each other. They all have their super cool bar / soccer related t shirts on and they enjoy a shot or two with the clientele. Food is awesome if a little pricey nowadays. Highly recommend the wings. Best wings in town in my personal opinion. That signature sauce!!! Yum!!!
We chose Chatham tap to watch the World Cup on a Sunday night, and was pleasantly surprised. We had a nice young man as a waiter, who was very attentive and helpful. Our food was fantastic for a sports bar. All TVs were on the soccer game, and overall, it saved our night because we had to walk out of the pub up the street on the corner, due to horrific service. Will be back!