Elizabeth made the most perfect wedding cake! I showed her inspo pictures for a 3 tier vintage piping cake and she exceeded my expectations! The cake not only looked beautiful but also tasted amazing! She is extremely talented and I can’t thank her enough for being apart of our wedding day.
Olivia Yeley
-
April 19, 2025
Elizabeth did an amazing job with our cake! I showed her a 3-tier reference photo for the design that we wanted, even though we were only getting a 1-tier cutting cake…and it turned out BEAUTIFUL! She made our cream cheese, lemon, and blueberry cake come to life, and we couldn’t be more grateful. We are saving half of it to freeze & eat on our anniversary, and I am sure it will taste just as good! DEFINITELY book with her!
Samantha Hilliard
-
October 04, 2025
They made sure my wedding was as special as I wanted it! The cupcakes and cake were absolutely delicious and our guests raved about them trying the different flavors we ordered!
Emma Buck
-
July 10, 2025
My husband and I are incredibly grateful to Elizabeth with Butter & Batter Bakery for creating the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake for our big day! She crafted a stunning 4-tier barrel cake along with a sheet cake to ensure we had plenty for all of our guests - and both were absolutely DELICIOUS! Not only was the cake exactly what I envisioned (both in design and flavor), but Elizabeth went the extra miler by delivering everything to our venue - for a very reasonable fee. That gesture alone helped ease so much stress on the day of our wedding and allowed us to focus on the moment without worrying about transportation or set up. She was incredibly easy to work with from start to finish: responsive, professional, and genuinely passionate about her work. You can truly tell how much love and care she puts into her baking. We got so many compliments on the cake from our guests -- both for how it looked, and how it tasted! If you're looking for someone who's not only incredibly talented but also kind, dependable, and willing to go the extra mile, we cannot recommend Butter & Batter Bakery enough!
Logan Schrader
-
February 13, 2025
great experience with Elizabeth, very short notice on the wedding cake and she was able to provide a quick turn around and she made a beautiful and incredibly tasty cake. it was the perfect balance of sweet and moist and everything was perfect. highly recommend
Our Address
2977 S 1000 W, Lapel, IN 46051, USA
Claim Listing: Butter & Batter Bakery
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Elizabeth made the most perfect wedding cake! I showed her inspo pictures for a 3 tier vintage piping cake and she exceeded my expectations! The cake not only looked beautiful but also tasted amazing! She is extremely talented and I can’t thank her enough for being apart of our wedding day.
Elizabeth did an amazing job with our cake! I showed her a 3-tier reference photo for the design that we wanted, even though we were only getting a 1-tier cutting cake…and it turned out BEAUTIFUL! She made our cream cheese, lemon, and blueberry cake come to life, and we couldn’t be more grateful. We are saving half of it to freeze & eat on our anniversary, and I am sure it will taste just as good! DEFINITELY book with her!
They made sure my wedding was as special as I wanted it! The cupcakes and cake were absolutely delicious and our guests raved about them trying the different flavors we ordered!
My husband and I are incredibly grateful to Elizabeth with Butter & Batter Bakery for creating the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake for our big day! She crafted a stunning 4-tier barrel cake along with a sheet cake to ensure we had plenty for all of our guests - and both were absolutely DELICIOUS! Not only was the cake exactly what I envisioned (both in design and flavor), but Elizabeth went the extra miler by delivering everything to our venue - for a very reasonable fee. That gesture alone helped ease so much stress on the day of our wedding and allowed us to focus on the moment without worrying about transportation or set up. She was incredibly easy to work with from start to finish: responsive, professional, and genuinely passionate about her work. You can truly tell how much love and care she puts into her baking. We got so many compliments on the cake from our guests -- both for how it looked, and how it tasted! If you're looking for someone who's not only incredibly talented but also kind, dependable, and willing to go the extra mile, we cannot recommend Butter & Batter Bakery enough!
great experience with Elizabeth, very short notice on the wedding cake and she was able to provide a quick turn around and she made a beautiful and incredibly tasty cake. it was the perfect balance of sweet and moist and everything was perfect. highly recommend