Casa Santa is truly a five-star experience! The food is absolutely delicious, every dish full of flavor and beautifully prepared. The environment is gorgeous—warm, inviting, and perfect for a special outing. On top of that, the service is outstanding. The staff goes above and beyond to make you feel welcomed and cared for.
Highly recommend!
Krista Powers
-
April 28, 2026
I arrived around 3:15 in the afternoon, and the restaurant was not busy at all. The host offered me the choice of a table or bar seating, and I chose the bar. There was plenty of open seating—only two other patrons were there, seated at the far end.
As I went to sit down, I chose the second seat instead of the first because the first had a gold rail that made the space feel a bit tight. The waitress asked me to move over one seat. When I asked why, she explained that they try to group single patrons together for strategic seating. While I can understand this approach during peak hours, it felt unnecessary given how empty the bar was at the time. I shared that I felt the request was a bit out of line, and she did apologize, but it still left me with a very bad first impression.
When my salsa was served, it was messy and overflowing. However, aside from those two issues, her service for the remainder of my visit was fine.
The food was excellent, and the restaurant itself is absolutely stunning—easily one of the most beautifully decorated places I’ve visited.
Mandy Lewis
-
May 01, 2026
This place is absolutely gorgeous, our server, Carolyn, was extremely attentive and friendly, and their Signature Cocktails are truly elevated (I got the Matadolores, which is like a Piña Colada, but better!!). Our entreés were delicious (Chimichanga and Fajitas!) and the churros and fried ice cream made for a perfectly sweet ending!).
Andy Goller
-
January 05, 2026
Always Superb Mexican food and great service. Beautiful restaurant that looks like a magazine—a feast for the eyes that elevates the experience.
The enchiladas are terrific, tacos tasty, salsa and chips delicious! Great beer and drink selections.
I am always happy to eat at Casa Santa. It feels more elegant than the bill would suggest.
Austin Jackson
-
March 07, 2026
I recently ate at Casa Santa and had mixed feelings about the experience. The food was actually really good. Everything tasted fresh, the portions were solid, and the flavors were exactly what you’d hope for when going out for Mexican food. I would definitely come back just for the food alone.
Unfortunately, the service at the beginning wasn’t great. Our waiter seemed to forget about us for long stretches of time until we asked what’s going on. We had to wait quite a while to order our food and to even get checked on. It felt like we were a bit overlooked compared to other tables.
Overall, the food was the highlight and definitely worth trying, but the service could really use some improvement.
Our Address
13521 Tegler Dr, Noblesville, IN 46060, USA
Claim Listing: Casa Santa Restaurant
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Casa Santa is truly a five-star experience! The food is absolutely delicious, every dish full of flavor and beautifully prepared. The environment is gorgeous—warm, inviting, and perfect for a special outing. On top of that, the service is outstanding. The staff goes above and beyond to make you feel welcomed and cared for. Highly recommend!
I arrived around 3:15 in the afternoon, and the restaurant was not busy at all. The host offered me the choice of a table or bar seating, and I chose the bar. There was plenty of open seating—only two other patrons were there, seated at the far end. As I went to sit down, I chose the second seat instead of the first because the first had a gold rail that made the space feel a bit tight. The waitress asked me to move over one seat. When I asked why, she explained that they try to group single patrons together for strategic seating. While I can understand this approach during peak hours, it felt unnecessary given how empty the bar was at the time. I shared that I felt the request was a bit out of line, and she did apologize, but it still left me with a very bad first impression. When my salsa was served, it was messy and overflowing. However, aside from those two issues, her service for the remainder of my visit was fine. The food was excellent, and the restaurant itself is absolutely stunning—easily one of the most beautifully decorated places I’ve visited.
This place is absolutely gorgeous, our server, Carolyn, was extremely attentive and friendly, and their Signature Cocktails are truly elevated (I got the Matadolores, which is like a Piña Colada, but better!!). Our entreés were delicious (Chimichanga and Fajitas!) and the churros and fried ice cream made for a perfectly sweet ending!).
Always Superb Mexican food and great service. Beautiful restaurant that looks like a magazine—a feast for the eyes that elevates the experience. The enchiladas are terrific, tacos tasty, salsa and chips delicious! Great beer and drink selections. I am always happy to eat at Casa Santa. It feels more elegant than the bill would suggest.
I recently ate at Casa Santa and had mixed feelings about the experience. The food was actually really good. Everything tasted fresh, the portions were solid, and the flavors were exactly what you’d hope for when going out for Mexican food. I would definitely come back just for the food alone. Unfortunately, the service at the beginning wasn’t great. Our waiter seemed to forget about us for long stretches of time until we asked what’s going on. We had to wait quite a while to order our food and to even get checked on. It felt like we were a bit overlooked compared to other tables. Overall, the food was the highlight and definitely worth trying, but the service could really use some improvement.