I called in at 8:20 today to place an order for pickup. I got there 30 minutes later exactly when they said both pizza's would be ready for pickup. I get there, only one is ready and they were prepared to charge me 39.95 for a single cheese pizza. As she approaches the desk she says, "Oh they're just taking the other one out, I'll go get it." That was a lie, and they in fact had not put the other one in the oven. I waited for a while and when she came back out I said, "The other one hasn't been put in yet has it?" She nodded and said, "No I'm sorry we've been backed up like crazy." I turned around and there was literally not one customer in the restaurant or anyone else waiting behind me. After waiting for them to cook the other one, I they apparently screwed up another order and I heard all of them gathering around the phone apologizing for messing up the other customers order. The guy working there then asked the girl, "Why aren't you clocked in." Her response was, "Because I don't work here." That was it, and I left. They can keep both of their pizza's and I'm never coming back. I loved Greek's in Westfield, but I hope this location goes under. How do you screw up two large pizzas, one cheese and one sausage? What a joke and an embarrassment.
Sarah Hartman
-
July 18, 2025
Delicious pizza and breadstick at a good price, staff were friendly and online order was ready by the time I arrived.
Tiffany L
-
December 27, 2023
Ordered carryout and was ready on time. We got bbq chicken pizza and garden veggie which were both pretty good. The crust is great, soft but crunchy. We were disappointed that the bbq chicken pizza DID NOT have any bbq sauce though so not sure what happened. It was just plain normal sauce. We would try again some time.
Derek Hudson
-
May 17, 2026
Do yourself a favor and don’t get garlic as a topping. Cause my pizza was loaded down with at least 5 tablespoons worth of minced garlic. Hundreds of pieces on one slice, a sarcastic amount of garlic. Pizza was uncooked so all the garlic was still raw. Couldn’t even eat it, wasted my money and my cheat meal for the week.
Daniel Petry
-
December 19, 2025
My favorite pizza in town, never disappoints. Decided to dine in today and had a great experience. The pizza was great as always and staff were very friendly. Highly recommend
Our Address
6317 Doctor M.L.K. Jr Blvd, Anderson, IN 46013, USA
Claim Listing: Greek’s Pizzeria
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I called in at 8:20 today to place an order for pickup. I got there 30 minutes later exactly when they said both pizza's would be ready for pickup. I get there, only one is ready and they were prepared to charge me 39.95 for a single cheese pizza. As she approaches the desk she says, "Oh they're just taking the other one out, I'll go get it." That was a lie, and they in fact had not put the other one in the oven. I waited for a while and when she came back out I said, "The other one hasn't been put in yet has it?" She nodded and said, "No I'm sorry we've been backed up like crazy." I turned around and there was literally not one customer in the restaurant or anyone else waiting behind me. After waiting for them to cook the other one, I they apparently screwed up another order and I heard all of them gathering around the phone apologizing for messing up the other customers order. The guy working there then asked the girl, "Why aren't you clocked in." Her response was, "Because I don't work here." That was it, and I left. They can keep both of their pizza's and I'm never coming back. I loved Greek's in Westfield, but I hope this location goes under. How do you screw up two large pizzas, one cheese and one sausage? What a joke and an embarrassment.
Delicious pizza and breadstick at a good price, staff were friendly and online order was ready by the time I arrived.
Ordered carryout and was ready on time. We got bbq chicken pizza and garden veggie which were both pretty good. The crust is great, soft but crunchy. We were disappointed that the bbq chicken pizza DID NOT have any bbq sauce though so not sure what happened. It was just plain normal sauce. We would try again some time.
Do yourself a favor and don’t get garlic as a topping. Cause my pizza was loaded down with at least 5 tablespoons worth of minced garlic. Hundreds of pieces on one slice, a sarcastic amount of garlic. Pizza was uncooked so all the garlic was still raw. Couldn’t even eat it, wasted my money and my cheat meal for the week.
My favorite pizza in town, never disappoints. Decided to dine in today and had a great experience. The pizza was great as always and staff were very friendly. Highly recommend