Cool historical decor inside, however, everything else was dated and the floor was dirty inside.
The tangerine ice cream soft serve was amazing, famous for this I heard. The sloppy Joe was awesome, one of the best I've had, way better than Grandma's!
The prices are great, got both these items for five bucks. They also have a drive-thru which is convenient.
Sherie Bishop
-
May 01, 2025
We went through the drive through and ordered 2 small tangerine cones. The sign board doesn't say there is a higher price for tangerine. So when they told us the price we were really surprised. They were good but not sure if it was worth the extra .55 cents. Lol, yeah it probably was! I just think the sign board should have said so.
Kerri Saunders
-
September 05, 2023
This is my first experience at Jimmy's S dairy bar. The staff was very friendly and helpful and very patient.
There was a large group of us and they were more than happy to take their time. All of the treats were delicious, everyone seemed to be very happy.
Undead
-
April 22, 2025
Haven't ate here in years... Sigh
Who the heck puts green peppers in their baked beans?? The malt was runny, not thick. BBQ sandwich musta changed recipes cus it was not what I remembered. Manager seems a little odd she kept talking very loud at the employees. Will not return unfortunately. Refills are NOT free.
Kraig Cassidy
-
May 16, 2025
Since 1954 "best bbq in Indiana" is a wild claim, idk if this place was ever anything special.. but it definitely is not now.. almost $10 bucks for a medium drink and a terrible coney dog is wild even in today's economy. This place is not it for me.
Our Address
Pendleton, IN 46064, USA
Claim Listing: Jimmie’s Dairy Bar
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Cool historical decor inside, however, everything else was dated and the floor was dirty inside. The tangerine ice cream soft serve was amazing, famous for this I heard. The sloppy Joe was awesome, one of the best I've had, way better than Grandma's! The prices are great, got both these items for five bucks. They also have a drive-thru which is convenient.
We went through the drive through and ordered 2 small tangerine cones. The sign board doesn't say there is a higher price for tangerine. So when they told us the price we were really surprised. They were good but not sure if it was worth the extra .55 cents. Lol, yeah it probably was! I just think the sign board should have said so.
This is my first experience at Jimmy's S dairy bar. The staff was very friendly and helpful and very patient. There was a large group of us and they were more than happy to take their time. All of the treats were delicious, everyone seemed to be very happy.
Haven't ate here in years... Sigh Who the heck puts green peppers in their baked beans?? The malt was runny, not thick. BBQ sandwich musta changed recipes cus it was not what I remembered. Manager seems a little odd she kept talking very loud at the employees. Will not return unfortunately. Refills are NOT free.
Since 1954 "best bbq in Indiana" is a wild claim, idk if this place was ever anything special.. but it definitely is not now.. almost $10 bucks for a medium drink and a terrible coney dog is wild even in today's economy. This place is not it for me.