Cool historical decor inside, however, everything else was dated and the floor was dirty inside.
The tangerine ice cream soft serve was amazing, famous for this I heard. The sloppy Joe was awesome, one of the best I've had, way better than Grandma's!
The prices are great, got both these items for five bucks. They also have a drive-thru which is convenient.
Monkey Stomp
-
April 08, 2026
I was unprepared for how bad the food was. I had heard mixed reviews, but seriously...I believe it's the worst BBQ I've ever had. The fries were boring and plain. The coleslaw was too sweet. Between the BBQ and the coleslaw being so sugary, I skipped the ice cream.
The service was disinterested at best. I believed some customers walked out after complaining about someone in the kitchen being rude.
As a topper, it's April and it's 80 degrees in the dining room.
k nibs
-
October 06, 2025
Not great, not terrible. The tenderloin was a formerly-frozen glorified fritter rather than house-made, but I happen to like them both. The fries were absolutely nothing special. The baked beans were just weird, in an over-the-top sweet, orange-color, water/sauce that tasted only of green bell peppers. Because they were loaded with green bell peppers. Very odd. The chocolate shake wasn't terrible but something was a little off. Idk.
I've driven by many times and finally stopped in. Now I can cross it off the list. If someone else is buying, I'd eat here again.
Sarah Hartman
-
July 20, 2025
Soft service ice cream in multiple flavors and one beautiful chocolate malt. Absolutely delicious 10/10 no notes.
Kerri Saunders
-
September 05, 2023
This is my first experience at Jimmy's S dairy bar. The staff was very friendly and helpful and very patient.
There was a large group of us and they were more than happy to take their time. All of the treats were delicious, everyone seemed to be very happy.
Our Address
Pendleton, IN 46064, USA
Claim Listing: Jimmie’s Dairy Bar
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Cool historical decor inside, however, everything else was dated and the floor was dirty inside. The tangerine ice cream soft serve was amazing, famous for this I heard. The sloppy Joe was awesome, one of the best I've had, way better than Grandma's! The prices are great, got both these items for five bucks. They also have a drive-thru which is convenient.
I was unprepared for how bad the food was. I had heard mixed reviews, but seriously...I believe it's the worst BBQ I've ever had. The fries were boring and plain. The coleslaw was too sweet. Between the BBQ and the coleslaw being so sugary, I skipped the ice cream. The service was disinterested at best. I believed some customers walked out after complaining about someone in the kitchen being rude. As a topper, it's April and it's 80 degrees in the dining room.
Not great, not terrible. The tenderloin was a formerly-frozen glorified fritter rather than house-made, but I happen to like them both. The fries were absolutely nothing special. The baked beans were just weird, in an over-the-top sweet, orange-color, water/sauce that tasted only of green bell peppers. Because they were loaded with green bell peppers. Very odd. The chocolate shake wasn't terrible but something was a little off. Idk. I've driven by many times and finally stopped in. Now I can cross it off the list. If someone else is buying, I'd eat here again.
Soft service ice cream in multiple flavors and one beautiful chocolate malt. Absolutely delicious 10/10 no notes.
This is my first experience at Jimmy's S dairy bar. The staff was very friendly and helpful and very patient. There was a large group of us and they were more than happy to take their time. All of the treats were delicious, everyone seemed to be very happy.